If you are looking to know all about the difference between willow and oak wood, you’re at the right place.
Willow and oak are two popular species of hardwood, which are recognized and used for their respective characteristics. While oak wood is prized for its incredible strength and durability, making it ideal for a range of applications, willow wood is known for its natural shock resistance, which makes it suitable for sports equipment like cricket bats and tools.
In this article, we take a deep dive into the world of hardwoods and will particularly talk about willow wood and oak timber as well as discuss the difference between the two in terms of appearance, strength, durability, workability, price, and uses. Let’s go.
What is Willow wood?
White Willow, one of the most popular willow species, has the scientific name Salix alba and is native to Europe and western and central Asia. The trees grow about 65-100 ft tall and have a 3-4 ft trunk diameter. The average dried weight is 25 lbs/ft3. With a 570 lbf Janka rating, white willow is a soft hardwood. The heartwood is tan to pinkish brown and has a straight grain and fine to medium texture. It’s rated as non-durable and is susceptible to insects.
White Willow is moderately priced in regions where it is available. It is used for baskets, furniture, cricket bats, and more. Despite poor machining characteristics, it glues and finishes well.
What is Oak Wood?
White Oak (Quercus alba) is found in the Eastern United States. The trees are about 65-85 ft tall with a 3-4 ft trunk diameter. Its heartwood is light to medium brown and has an olive cast, and the grain is straight with a coarse texture.
With a Janka Hardness of 1,350 lbf, white oak is a very strong and durable wood, making it popular for boatbuilding and cooperage applications. However, other species such as red oak are not as durable.
White Oak is easy to work with both hand and machine tools, though it has moderate shrinkage and may react with wet iron causing staining. Depending on availability, the price is moderate to expensive. The wood is used for cabinetry, furniture, flooring, boatbuilding, and more applications..
Willow vs Oak Wood
The major difference between oak and willow is in terms of hardness. While oak is hard and strong, willow is more flexible, making the two woods suitable for different applications. If you’re planning a woodworking project with either willow or oak timber, make sure to explore and research the differences between the two before you make a decision.
Oak and Willow wood exhibit slightly distinct appearances.
White Oak has a light to medium brown heartwood with an olive cast and a straight grain. Ray fleck patterns are noticeable on quartersawn sections.
In contrast, White Willow has tan to pinkish brown heartwood and yellowish white sapwood, and a straight grain. The texture is fine to medium uniform.
Oak’s appearance is characterized by traditional elegance and classiness, making it popular for furniture and other interior applications. Willow, historically used for cricket bats, is valued for its lightweight nature and flexibility.
In terms of strength, Oak and Willow wood differ significantly.
White Oak is renowned for its hardness and strength due to its high Janka Hardness of 1,350 lbf, which also makes it quite durable and well-suited for high-end applications like boatbuilding. It is naturally resistant to rot and insect attack.
On the other hand, White Willow is comparatively weaker. As a lightweight hardwood with a low Janka rating, it is not very hard or durable. Willow provides good shock resistance, but it is considered weak for its weight.
Oak’s strength and durability contribute to its robustness and longevity. It is extensively used in heavy-duty applications, construction, outdoor furniture, flooring, etc., whereas Willow is rather soft and cannot withstand as much stress and strain.
Oak’s durability depends on its species. While red oak is considered non-durable, white oak is incredibly durable and has outstanding resistance to rot.
White Oak is rated as very durable, making it suitable for applications like boatbuilding. Its resistance to decay makes it last long, even when used outside. Red oak, however, is not durable at all.
White Willow is rated as non-durable to perishable in terms of resistance to decay and environmental factors. It may not withstand exposure to the natural elements as well as Oak.
Despite being hard and dense, White Oak is known for being easy to work with both hand and machine tools. It has moderately high shrinkage levels but responds well to steam-bending and is also easy to glue, stain, and finish.
White Willow might sometimes pose challenges due to its low density, especially in machining operations. Fuzzy surfaces are common. It can be difficult to season and dries with defects. However, it glues and finishes rather well. Oak’s workability and versatility are favored by woodworkers, while Willow requires more careful handling.
Price & Availability
White Oak is abundant and is usually available in a range of sizes, including both flatsawn and quartersawn, especially in its native regions, where it is reasonably priced. However, the price for imported oak hardwood can be higher. White is usually more expensive than Red Oak.
White Willow’s price depends on its availability. In its native regions, the price is low to moderate. Other species, like Black Willow, are also readily available and moderately priced.
White Oak and White Willow find diverse applications due to their distinct characteristics. White Oak, which is strong, durable, and beautiful, is favored for a wide range of general applications, including cabinetry, furniture, interior trim, flooring, boatbuilding, barrels, and veneer.
White Willow was historically used for making cricket bats but is also utilized in baskets, boxes, utility wood, crates, carvings, and small specialty wood items.
Willow’s lightweight nature, flexibility, and shock resistance make it suitable for specific applications, while White Oak is considered suitable for all kinds of projects.
Willow vs Oak : Which is Better?
The choice between oak and willow is simple. If you are looking for a strong and durable wood that is also easy to work with, oak is an obvious choice. But if you are looking for flexibility and stability with good shock resistance, choose Willow Wood. I hope this article about the differences between oak wood and willow timber helps you make the right choice.
If you are looking to buy high-quality hardwood at the best price in the market, please visit our official website or contact (call/Whatsapp) us at +237671776559 to discuss your timber requirements and enquire about price and availability. We are a premier seller and exporter of hardwood timber in North America, Australia, the UK, Europe, the Middle East, and Asia.